Young man in a dark room on his cell phone.
Published on:

Post-9/11 veterans who used minimally moderated, ideologically oriented social media platforms reported greater concern about the condition of U.S. democracy and less satisfaction with the end of the war in Afghanistan than veterans who used other social media platforms or no social media at all, according to a new study by Penn State researchers.

The study, recently published in the Journal of Veterans Studies, analyzed survey responses from nearly 3,000 veterans to examine how social media habits relate to views on democracy, personal freedoms and other social conditions.

“Social media can help veterans find information, support and a sense of community as they adjust to civilian life,” said Cameron Richardson, a research and evaluation scientist at the Clearinghouse for Military Family Readiness at Penn State (Clearinghouse) and lead researcher on the study. “At the same time, these platforms expose veterans to information and viewpoints that may shape how they see the world. We wanted to better understand the relationship between the platforms veterans use and their perceptions of democracy.”

The study drew data from The Veterans Metrics Initiative and Veterans Engaging in Transition Studies, which tracked veterans who left military service in 2016. The researchers analyzed responses collected in March 2023, approximately six and a half years after participants separated from the military.

Participants indicated which social media platforms they used, their concern about democracy in America and their satisfaction with the end of the 20-year war in Afghanistan. They also evaluated whether five social conditions were improving, staying the same or worsening: protections of personal freedoms, younger generations’ prospects for being better off than their parents, the ability to hear a wide range of political views, civic and political engagement, and equal rights and protections.

Researchers divided participants into three groups:

  • Minimally Moderated/Ideologically Oriented (MM/IO) users: Those who used Truth Social, Parler or both.
  • Non-MM/IO users: Those who used social media outlets other than Truth Social and Parler.
  • Non-social media users: Those who did not use social media.

Overall, 85% of respondents used at least one social media platform. Facebook was the most popular platform at 66%, followed by YouTube at 50% and Instagram at 45%. Truth Social and Parler were used by only 2% and 1% of respondents, respectively.

Among the 85 MM/IO users, 58% used Truth Social only, 28% used Parler only, and 14% used both.

On a 5-point scale, with higher scores indicating a greater concern, MM/IO users reported an average concern about democracy of 4.31, compared with 3.69 among non-MM/IO social media users and 3.57 among non-social media users.

Sixty percent of MM/IO platform users reported being extremely concerned about democracy, compared with 32.5% of non-MM/IO users and 34.6% of non-social media users.

This negative outlook extended to all five measured social conditions as well. MM/IO users gave lower average ratings across all categories than the other two groups. However, concern was widespread across the sample, with respondents in all three groups viewing each condition as worsening on average.

A similar pattern emerged in views on the war's end in Afghanistan. On a 5-point scale ranging from 1 for “very dissatisfied” to 5 for “very satisfied,” MM/IO users averaged a satisfaction score of 1.52, compared with 2.20 for non-MM/IO users and 2.02 for non-social media users.

About 74% of MM/IO users reported being very dissatisfied with the withdrawal, compared with 40% of non-MM/IO users and 48% of non-users.

MM/IO users also engaged with more platforms overall, averaging 4.16 social media outlets compared to 2.63 for non-MM/IO users. Nearly all MM/IO users—80 out of 85—also used at least one mainstream platform.

The researchers pointed out that access to multiple platforms did not necessarily mean more exposure to diverse perspectives. The survey identified platform usage but did not track specific posts, recommendation algorithms or consumed content, leaving open whether participants sought out varying viewpoints or consumed similar messaging across platforms.

Although the study did not directly measure exposure to radicalizing content or support for political violence, the authors noted that military-connected individuals are frequently targeted by outside actors with misinformation and disinformation, especially on minimally moderated platforms. These campaigns often co-opt military terminology and iconography, framing movements as “digital armies,” tactics as “meme warfare” and disinformation as “ammunition.”

“Veterans are a respected group, and that makes efforts to influence them online a concern that extends beyond the veteran community,” said co-author Keith Aronson, director of the Clearinghouse, part of the Social Science Research Institute, and research professor in the Department of Biobehavioral Health. “We need to help veterans recognize misleading information while preserving the connections and support they find online.”

To address these challenges, the researchers recommended incorporating formal media literacy training prior to military separation. This training would emphasize evaluating source credibility, recognizing manipulative content and understanding algorithmic media delivery.

The authors also noted several study limitations. For instance, the data show associations rather than direct causation, leaving unresolved whether platform participation shapes political views or whether the platforms primarily attract individuals whose pre-existing beliefs align with the content they consume. Additionally, the study did not account for television news, radio or podcast consumption, nor could it include newer MM/IO platforms like Bluesky, which launched after data collection and is considered an online space that stands in contrast to spaces like Truth Social and Parler. The researchers plan to expand the next wave of the survey to include newer MM/IO platforms like Bluesky.

“Social connection is an important part of the transition to civilian life, and online communities can help veterans maintain those ties,” said co-author Daniel F. Perkins, principal scientist and founder of the Clearinghouse and distinguished professor of family and youth resiliency and policy in the College of Agricultural Sciences. “As we help veterans find support, we also need to help them evaluate the information they encounter. Both deserve attention in how we prepare and assist veterans after military service.”

Other contributors to the study include Timothy Mazer, research project manager at the Clearinghouse, and Ryan P. Chesnut, assistant research professor at the Clearinghouse.

The research was supported by the Wounded Warrior Project, The Heinz Endowments, May & Stanley Smith Charitable Trust, and The Arthur M. Blank Family Foundation. This work is the sole responsibility of the authors and does not necessarily reflect the views of the funders.